UPDATE: I’ve amended this to remove most of what could be considered spoiler material but you may still want to be careful if you haven’t read the book and don’t know what happens. I apologise in advance (I hate it when I inadvertantly come across spoilers) but consider this fair warning! And apologies to Fluff who didn’t get any such notice at all!
The main problem I have with the book Return of the King is that all the action ends about half way through and the last half of the book (before the 200 pages or so of appendices) is all about the aftermath of the War of the Ring. In that sense the cinematic version seems to have done the book justice, but more on that later.
What�s my first feeling about this movie? To be honest, it�s one of anti-climax. Peter Jackson�s films highlight the shortcomings of the book itself and that is simply that some of it is astoundingly cheesy. How the actors managed to deliver some of the dialogue and keep a straight face is quite beyond me. Except that the reason it�s all so corny is because of everything that has come between the book and the film, all those awful films which tried to emulate Lord of the Rings fell into the pit of becoming a self-parody, with one or two exceptions.
But what does save Lord of the Rings is, well, everything about it. The dialogue may at times be cheesier than the UN Gorgonzola mountain, but the language is so rich and poetic and the actors are so enthused that you can�t help but be captivatd by it all. And there is a good spattering of humour thrown into the mix too which breaks up all the earnest dramatic scenes of bravery and valour.
Set that against the epic spectacle that has been missing from cinemas for so long and you start to get an idea of why Return of the King is a great film. Forget what you�ve seen in recent epics like Gladiator and Braveheart, this film harks back to the days of Spartacus and Lawrence of Arabia for sheer scale and grandiose. The effects are so good that I could have believed that there were 20,000 extras lined up on the plains outside of a full size set of Minas Tirith. I was blown away by the aerial camerawork swooping in low over the massed armies of orcs and men as they struggled on the battlefields and it was an awesome sight to behold.
But the grandeur of the battle scenes were elegantly juxtaposed next to the quieter, more intimate scenes, some heart warming, some heart rending, such as the poignant scene when Pippin sings to Denethor in the great hall. And this in turn was set against the scenes filled with suspense where Jackson gave away his roots in horror film directing. Arachnophobe or not, the scenes with Shelob were very terrifying and I wouldn�t be lying to say that everyone in the audience was on the edge of their seats. Return of the King has it all, drama, humour, horror, action… the list goes on.
The reviews I�ve read so far all have reservations about the fact that there are several endings to the film and it is definitely a weak point of the film although as I mentioned earlier, I feel this is more to do with the original source material. The ending is already vastly different from the book and totally does away with some key scenes in the book (and it should be added that the decision to take these scenes out is a wise move, cinematically) but I don�t feel that any of the scenes we do see are extraneous. Perhaps if they�d have been edited slightly more differently then it wouldn�t have been so obvious and I will await the Extended Edition on DVD with anticipation to see if they add any more to it.
In fact, I�ll be awaiting the extended version eagerly anyway as, despite the three and a half hour running time, I wanted to see more, a lot more. I could have easily sat there for another hour or so to see more of the battles, more of Sam and Frodo�s journey through Mordor, more of the aftermath. Because at the end of the day, as much as I instinctively feel that it was an anti-climax, I felt the same way about the first two films the first time I saw them and I think it�s because one viewing is not enough to take in the rich tapestry of what has been played out before me on the screen.
I do know that I don�t have enough space to tell you how wonderful it all was, how the scenery and the effects and the costumes and the production design and the performances and the direction and everything (did I mention the scenery? There should be a new Oscar for best use of a location!) was amazing. Stunning. Fantastic. And I�m really looking forward to seeing it again.