Concerning Home Birth
It’s coming up to a month since the birth of my daughter - I can’t believe how quickly it’s passed! So now I’m going to tell you a little more about giving birth at home (but don’t worry, I’m not going into detail about the minutiae.) The reason I asked if people wanted to know¹ about giving birth at home is because so many people have expressed surprise at our choice to do so, especially as we had kept the fact that we planned to have a home birth (as opposed to getting caught on the hop) pretty much to ourselves. The reason we did this is because of fleeting conversations we had with people who said things along the lines of “giving birth at home is crazy!” and “why would you risk it?” As we didn’t either want or feel the need to justify our decision, we decided that we’d only tell immediate family and very close friends.
Let me tell you right now: choosing a home birth for our second child was absolutely and definitely the right decision for us and it went wonderfully (although understand that this is coming from the point of view of a bloke and not someone who had to actually do the hard work.)
My son, who is coming up to two and a half years old, was born in a local hospital. The experience we had there was considerably more stressful and difficult than the second time around and was another reason why we chose to go for a home birth. It helped that we knew the local midwife (who has four children herself) and live in an area where there something like ten times the national average of home deliveries each year. We also know another mother - who happens to be a GP - who had seen this midwife resuscitate a baby that has just been born so we had confidence in her skills.
The comment we heard most was “But what if something went wrong?” and it’s a fair question. We deliberated and discussed this quite a lot between ourselves and with the midwife. We looked at alternatives, went to see both the hospital we’d have to go to (slightly further away thatn the nearest hospital to us which is 20 minutes away but in the same county) as well as looking at the (god-awful) birthing centre. We put together contingencies and we planned for the worst case scenario. (My wife even sat down with a friend of ours who was going to attend as well (seeing as how it was quite possible I’d be in Nottingham and not on hand) and told her that if the worst happened - i.e. she died - then there was to be no blame assigned.) We also trusted that our midwife would know when things weren’t going to plan and would be able to advise us on what we needed to do.
But, and here’s the rub, the chance of intervention during a home birth is probably lower than being in hospital because, generally, the environment is much more calm and conducive to a relaxed labour and birthing process. It’s familiar, it’s safe, it’s not at all clinical and, best of all, it’s home. Everything was set up exactly as my wife wanted it, music was playing, the bean bags were out, all that she wanted was to hand. Once we called the midwife and after the initial exam, all we did was sit around drinking tea and having a chat. Well, all apart from my wife who obviously had other things on her mind at the time.
And then, on the stroke of midnight, my wife gave birth to a beautiful little girl and an hour or so later, we were in our own bed, in our own house and not in some impersonal hospital ward surrounded by a load of noisy strangers. It was, even if I do say so myself, remarkably stress free.
Another benefit we’ve since discovered about giving birth at home is that our baby is remarkably calm. The midwife told us that, in her experience, babies born at home are generally calmer. You see, being in hospital and away from the safety and security of the nest is likely to cause a surge of adrenaline and this (so she reckons) will affect not only the nature of the birth but also the child. Certainly hatchling #2 has been absolute angel and so much more placid than her brother ever was so there may be something to it.
If someone asked us whether or not to go for a home birth, we’d recommend it wholeheartedly. We’d even think about having a third if it wasn’t for the prospect of nine months of morning (or at least, all the time) sickness that my wife would have to endure (which she described to me as having the worst hangover I could imagine every day for nine months without even the joy of having a drink the night before). There are provisos, of course, and a lot of thought needs to be given to it as it’s not necessarily the right thing for everybody but I would encourage people to think about it because that night was one of the most amazing and best experiences of my life. Although, of course, I didn’t have to have do something which has been equated to shitting out a melon!
¹Only one person replied so I’m guessing you don’t want to know about it but I’ve never been one to pander to my audience!

I think anything like Home Birth will always be thought of by the general public as “what’s the worst that could happen”. People always assume the worst, instead of assuming the best, but planning for the worst and having contingencies in place. If the worst thing that could possibly happen during a birth had happened, even if you were in a hospital you’re not exactly guaranteed that it’s all going to be okay.
Assume the best and it’s nearly always going to turn out that way. Assume the worst and it’s still probably going to turn out best, but you’re going to stress your way through the whole thing so much that you’ll probably make it worse all by yourself.
Sounds like from your experience the benefits far outweighed the possible problems.
Maybe I’m just an oblivious optimist.
Comment by Matt — May 23, 2008 @ 11:38 am
Wow! Congratulations to you and yours, Tom. That’s fantastic news.
I’d have loved a home birth but both of mine presented in a funny way (their backbones lay along my backbone).
I agree though, it’s an informed choice that more people would make if they could be supported.
Comment by Elinor — May 26, 2008 @ 1:21 pm
Hi Elinor. Hatchling #1 was born spine to spine (OP? Can’t remember what the term is) but started labour in the right position and seemed to turn half through. This was another reason we (particularly the wife) didn’t want to go back to hospital - they encouraged on lie on the bed and kept her there and after that, the problems started. Still didn’t need intervention (just!) but it could have been easier!
Comment by Tom — May 26, 2008 @ 7:46 pm
Congrats on being a dad!
And thanks for the nice comment on my blonk, it was very much appreciated.
Comment by Annie Rhiannon — May 27, 2008 @ 10:58 am
Hi Tom,
Big congratulations to you and your wife on the Hatchling #2. It’s wonderful to hear that it was a relaxing (well maybe not totally relaxing for the mother of the hatchling) experience compared to that of the hospital birth. You are lucky to have such good help nearby with a highly skilled and competent midwife. I am sure this being the second one, would have helped you guys some. I don’t have kids yet and if I do, I am not sure if I will have the guts to do it at home, seeing as I have never experienced it before and I’d be very nervous. But from your post I surely see the merit of comfort of home and familiarity and away from the horrible feeling of the hospital.
I am wishing the little one (name?) a long, happy and healthy life with her loved ones.
Gx
Comment by Gaye — June 4, 2008 @ 2:50 am
I know quite a few people who have opted for Home birth , especially for seconds and subsequents. And from everything I’ve heard and read it seems the right thing to do providing the circumstances are right. Actually, I have a lot of friends who were born at home in the Sixties. Both my parents were (20s and 30s).
That having been said, it isn’t right for everybody. But I also believe that a lot of people are favouring lo-tech maternity hospitals a bit like the ‘nursing homes’ and, er, maternity hospitals that were popular in decades gone by.
I had a discussion with a GP about five years. In the area he lived, they were downgrading the local general hospital and merging two city centre hospitals, so that the neo-natal ICU would be on the same site as the adult ICU. We both thought it was a brilliant idea being sold all wrong, because a consolidated city centre site was far far better for problematic cases, and the majority could opt for the local lo-tech site.
I just can’t see what the problem is having a straightforward birth at home, especially if there is a sufficient network of support. Lie in hospital getitng all sweaty, being disturbed by other people’s noise, running the risk of MRSA, having to travel. Or be at home with a decent cup of tea and an internet connection:-)
Comment by Gert — June 8, 2008 @ 4:38 pm
And that’s the other thing - me pontificating as if I knew anything - but hospitals make delivering mothers lie down, because that’s, oh so sensible and is bound to ease the pain.
Comment by Gert — June 8, 2008 @ 4:39 pm